Skip to main content

8 min read

Divorce Buyout of the House: How to Price It, With a Worksheet

A divorce buyout of the house, priced in order: the value, what is owed, the agreed split, the refinance hurdle, what you may give up in other assets, a blank worksheet, and what to ask before you agree.

A green hedgerow beneath a blue sky

A divorce buyout of the house is usually priced by taking its current value, subtracting the mortgage and any other loans against it, and applying the share you and your spouse agree on. Whether selling costs count depends on your state and your agreement. The refinance is a separate step. Ask your attorney how it applies to you.

That sentence hides several decisions, and each one moves the number. This guide walks through them in order and leaves the figures blank, because the right ones come from your own documents, not from an average. If you are still deciding whether to keep the house at all, start with how to keep the house in a divorce, which covers the carrying costs on one income. This page is about the buyout figure itself.

This guide is general education. I am a divorce financial consultant, not an attorney, so it does not say how any court or state treats your home.

The steps, in order

Depending on your situation, pricing a buyout may follow this sequence:

  1. Get an independent value. A current appraisal or a comparison of recent sales, ordered or agreed by both sides, not a listing-site estimate. The formula.
  2. Add up what is owed. The mortgage, any home equity loan or line of credit, and any other lien. The formula.
  3. Settle which costs count. Whether the cost of selling is subtracted, and whether the agreed split is of the equity or of something else. What changes the figure.
  4. Apply the agreed split. The share each of you is to receive, as your agreement describes it. The worksheet.
  5. Test the refinance. Whether you may qualify on your own income, and what the new payment may be. The refinance hurdle.
  6. Price what you may give up. The other assets you may take less of, valued after tax. The trade.
  7. Confirm the wording and the tax treatment. Your attorney writes the agreement, and a tax professional checks how it is likely to be treated. Who to ask what.

The buyout formula in words

Most buyout calculators ask for the same few inputs. Here they are in plain words, so you can see what each one does.

  • Current value. What the house may sell for today. An independent appraisal is usually a firmer starting point than an owner's estimate, because both sides are more likely to accept it.
  • Less what is owed. The mortgage balance plus any home equity loan, line of credit or other lien. What is left is the equity.
  • Times the agreed split. The share each person is to receive. Whether that is an even split or something else is a legal question that depends on your state and your agreement.
  • Equals the buyout figure. The amount the spouse keeping the house may owe the spouse leaving it, before any adjustment for other assets.

Put as a sentence: the buyout figure is the leaving spouse's share of the equity, where equity is value minus what is owed. Anything that changes the value, the debt or the split changes the figure, which is why each is worth checking before you rely on it.

What changes the figure

Small differences in the inputs can add up. These are the ones I would look at first.

  • Which value is used. Two appraisals can differ, and so can an appraisal and a recent-sales comparison. Ask whether both of you accept the same source, and what happens if you do not.
  • The date of the value and the debt. A balance changes as payments are made, and values move. Ask which date the agreement uses for each.
  • Selling costs. If the house were sold, commissions, closing costs and repairs would reduce what is left. Some agreements subtract an amount for these when one spouse keeps the house, and some do not. Whether they count depends on your state and on what you and your spouse agree. Your attorney can tell you how it is usually handled where you live.
  • Other liens and debts. A second loan, a line of credit or an unpaid tax bill against the house changes the equity.
  • Who paid down the loan, and when. Down payments, inherited money and payments made before the marriage may affect how the equity is treated. That is a question about property rules, so I leave it to your attorney.
  • Work or money put into the house. Improvements may raise the value, and an appraiser may or may not capture them. Keep the receipts.

None of this decides who is right. It tells you which questions have to be answered before the figure means anything.

The refinance hurdle

Pricing the buyout and paying for it are two different problems. Many lenders will not simply take one name off a loan. A refinance replaces the existing mortgage with a new one in your name, at whatever rate and terms are available then, and the lender decides whether you qualify.

Qualifying on one income is a hurdle of its own. A lender looks at the income you will have after the divorce. It may not count every source the same way, and it may ask how long any support is scheduled to last. A refinance can also include closing costs, and a new rate may be higher or lower than the old one.

Questions to ask a lender before you rely on any figure:

  • What income does the lender count on my own, and how does it treat support I would receive?
  • What documents does it need to see about support, such as the agreement or the order?
  • What payment, rate and closing costs might apply on my income alone, in writing?
  • What is the minimum equity or down payment it requires, and does the buyout payment count toward it?
  • How long does the process take, and how long is a quote good for?
  • What does it need before it will release my spouse from the existing loan?
  • If I do not qualify, what are my options, such as a co-signer, a different loan type, or selling?

Some people ask whether a buyout can happen without a refinance. It sometimes can, for example when the agreement gives a period of time to refinance, or when the existing loan can be handled in another way. A lender's terms vary, and changing who is on the deed does not by itself change who is responsible for the loan. Ask the lender what it permits and your attorney how the agreement should address it.

What a buyout may cost in other assets

If the buyout is paid through other assets rather than cash, the comparison needs care. A dollar of home equity and a dollar in a retirement account are not the same dollar. Money in a traditional retirement account has usually not been taxed yet, so what it is worth to you depends on taxes when it comes out. Cash is already after tax. Home equity is not income, and reaching it generally means selling, borrowing or refinancing.

That is why a buyout paid with retirement money may look even at face value and uneven after tax. Two guides cover the comparison in detail:

Run the same comparison for selling the house. Seeing the figures for both keeping and selling is the best check on whether the buyout price is one you may be comfortable with.

Tax pointers

Taxes are one of the places a buyout can look different on paper than it is in practice. These are general pointers, each tied to its source, and none of them is a statement about your tax situation.

  • Transfers between spouses. The IRS explains that, generally, no gain or loss is recognized on a transfer of property between spouses, or to a former spouse if the transfer is incident to the divorce, and that the person receiving the property generally takes over the other person's tax basis. The details are in the property settlements section of IRS Publication 504, Divorced or Separated Individuals.
  • Selling a home later. A transfer may not be taxed on the day it happens, but a tax cost may follow the house and arrive when it is later sold. The IRS explains the rules for selling a home, including a home received in a divorce, in IRS Publication 523, Selling Your Home.
  • Using other assets to pay. How withdrawals or transfers from different kinds of accounts are taxed is a separate question. IRS Publication 504 is the starting point for transfers, and the retirement guide above covers the account side.

Whether any of this applies to you depends on your facts. Please confirm it with a tax professional before you agree to a structure.

The worksheet

Print this or copy it into a spreadsheet. Every cell is blank on purpose. Fill it with figures from your own documents, mark each one as firm or estimated, and note the date and source.

Step 1: The equity

LineItemAmountSource and date
ACurrent value of the house
BMortgage balance
CHome equity loan or line of credit
DOther liens or debts against the house
EEquity (A minus B, C and D)

Step 2: Selling costs, if your agreement counts them

LineItemAmountSource and date
FEstimated cost of selling
GEquity after selling costs (E minus F)

Step 3: The buyout figure

LineItemAmount or shareSource and date
HAgreed share going to the spouse leaving
IBuyout figure (E or G, times H)
JOther assets you would take less of, to offset it
KCash needed, if any (I minus J)

Step 4: Can you carry it?

ItemAmountSource and date
New mortgage payment quoted in your name
Property tax, insurance, utilities and fees, yearly
Yearly allowance for repairs
Closing costs on the refinance
Your expected yearly income, with and without support

Step 5: The comparison

OptionWhat I would have in accessible savingsWhat I would have in retirement accounts, after taxMonthly difference in my budget
Keep the house, with the buyout
Sell the house and divide the proceeds

If you have not yet built a budget for one household, how to build a divorce budget, with a worksheet is a useful place to start, since several of these inputs come from it.

Ask before you agree

Before you sign anything that settles the house, I would want answers to these:

  • Has the house been valued by someone independent of both of us, and do we both accept that value?
  • Which date does the agreement use for the value and for the loan balance?
  • Are selling costs counted in the buyout figure, and does the wording say so?
  • What share is the buyout based on, and where is that written?
  • Have I seen a lender's written quote for a refinance in my name, on my income alone?
  • What does the lender need to release my spouse from the loan, and what does the agreement say if I cannot refinance?
  • If other assets offset the buyout, have I valued them after tax and not at face value?
  • Has a tax professional looked at how the transfer and any sale later may be treated?
  • What happens if I need to sell later, and are there costs or terms tied to that?
  • Have I seen the figures for selling as well as keeping?

When to bring in other people

Each of these questions belongs to a different professional:

  • Your attorney answers questions about the law and the agreement: how your state treats the house, what share applies, whether selling costs count, and how the buyout and the loan should be written.
  • A lender answers whether you can qualify on your own, at what rate and payment, and what it takes to release a name from the loan.
  • A tax professional answers what the transfer, a later sale or the use of other assets may mean for your taxes.
  • A divorce financial consultant, which is the work I do, puts the numbers beside each other so the comparison above is done before you decide, and explains what each option may look like over time.

Frequently asked questions

How is a house buyout calculated in a divorce?

In general terms, the equity is the current value minus what is owed on the house, and the buyout figure is the leaving spouse's agreed share of that equity. Whether selling costs are subtracted, which value is used and what share applies depend on your state and your agreement. Your attorney can tell you how those points are usually handled where you live.

Is a divorce buyout taxable?

It depends on your situation. The IRS explains in Publication 504 that, generally, a transfer of property between spouses, or to a former spouse incident to the divorce, does not result in recognized gain or loss, and that the person receiving the property generally takes over the other person's tax basis. A tax cost may follow the house and arrive when it is later sold, as Publication 523 explains. A tax professional can tell you how it may apply to you.

Can I do a buyout without refinancing?

Sometimes. A lender usually has to agree before one spouse is released from a loan, so a refinance is common, but some agreements give a period of time to refinance, or handle the loan another way. Ask your attorney how the agreement should address it, and ask the lender what it permits.

Do selling costs come out of a divorce buyout?

They may, or they may not. Some agreements subtract an amount for selling costs when one spouse keeps the house, and some do not. It depends on your state and on what you and your spouse agree, so ask your attorney, and make sure the agreement says which approach applies.

Is there a divorce buyout calculator I can use?

The worksheet above is a blank calculator you can copy into a spreadsheet. Online calculators can be a quick check, but they usually leave out selling costs, the refinance and the value of what you give up elsewhere. The figures should come from your own records.

What if I cannot afford to buy my spouse out?

There may be other options, such as taking more of another asset, agreeing a period to refinance, or selling the house and dividing what is left. Price each one on the same worksheet before you decide. Your attorney can tell you which options may be open to you.

What to do with this

Fill in the first block of the worksheet with a value and the loan balances, then ask a lender for a written quote on your income alone. Run the same figures for selling. Take the questions to your attorney and a tax professional before you agree to anything.

If you would like the arithmetic done alongside you, this is the work I do, and the first conversation is complimentary.

This is general education about a common decision, not advice about your situation, and it is not legal, tax or investment advice. Rules about property, loans and taxes vary by state and by circumstance, so confirm them with your attorney, lender and a tax professional.

Seeing your own numbers helps more than reading about someone else’s.

Bring me the question this raised, and we can put real figures against it.

Consultations are complimentary and confidential.